Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://repository.isls.org/handle/1/2321
Full metadata record
DC FieldValueLanguage
dc.contributor.authorOviatt, Sharon
dc.contributor.authorHodge, Kumi
dc.contributor.authorMiller, Andrea
dc.date.accessioned2020-01-08T16:51:16Z
dc.date.accessioned2020-01-08T22:04:03Z-
dc.date.available2020-01-08T16:51:16Z
dc.date.available2020-01-08T22:04:03Z-
dc.date.issued2012-07
dc.identifier.citationOviatt, S., Hodge, K., & Miller, A. (2012). Computer Input Capabilities that Stimulate Diagramming and Improved Inferential Reasoning in Low-performing Students. In van Aalst, J., Thompson, K., Jacobson, M. J., & Reimann, P. (Eds.), The Future of Learning: Proceedings of the 10th International Conference of the Learning Sciences (ICLS 2012) – Volume 2, Short Papers, Symposia, and Abstracts (pp. 451-452). Sydney, NSW, AUSTRALIA: International Society of the Learning Sciences.en_US
dc.identifier.urihttps://doi.dx.org/10.22318/icls2012.2.451
dc.identifier.urihttps://repository.isls.org//handle/1/2321-
dc.description.abstractThis study explores the question: Compared wit a non-digital pen does a digital pen interface a e affordances t at elicit more diagramming and also more correct inferences a out corresponding domain content Students solved inferential reasoning problems while using: (1) non-digital pen and paper, (2) digital pen and paper interface. They averaged more diagrams, 14% more correct enn diagrams, and 9.4% more correct domain inferences when using the digital pen interface. An error analysis further revealed that construction of multiple diagrams effectively suppressed scoping errors (e.g. overgeneralizations), the most common inference error. Implications are discussed for designing educational interfaces that improve students' visual fluency skills and related reasoning abilities, especially in low performers. ntroduction and ypotheses ne important ob ective for the design of future educational interfaces is to stimulate basic thinking and reasoning, including reducing systematic errors that undermine cognition. Recent research has highlighted that digital pen interfaces can substantially facilitate thinking by supporting the expression of different types of representation (e.g., linguistic, diagram, symbol, number). They elicit 44% more nonlinguistic representations, like diagrams, compared with keyboard-based computer interfaces ( viatt, in press; viatt, iller & Hodge, in press). iagramming can make information more visually available to think about, especially if it is well matched with a task domain and makes alternatives visually explicit (Bauer & ohnson-Laird, 1993). ast research has revealed that communicating more nonlinguistic content simultaneously stimulates a 36% higher level of appropriate biology hypotheses. Furthermore, knowledge of students' level of nonlinguistic communication predicted 72% of the total variance in their idea production ( viatt, in press). Related findings demonstrated that students' active construction of diagrams and marks also were associated with 25-36% higher problem-solution scores, compared with matched problems in which students did no diagramming or marking ( viatt, in press). These findings support an Activity theory view that communicative activity directly mediates thought, if well matched with a task domain. They also emphasize the importance of designing educational interfaces that support nonlinguistic representations as an aid in thinking, especially spatial ones like diagrams. The current research specifically explores whether: A digital pen will elicit more diagrams and more correct enn diagrams, compared with a non-digital pen A digital pen will selectively stimulate a higher percentage of correct inferences when students diagram ultiple diagramming will suppress overgeneralization errors, improving inference accuracy ethods articipants were twenty-three low-performing English speakers between 18 and 24 years of age, half male and female. All were expert users of keyboard interfaces, but none had ever used a digital pen interface. They solved three-statement inference problems by producing as many valid conclusions as possible, half using an Anoto- based digital pen and paper interface and half using a regular pen and paper. Students learned that the digital pen was a computer that could interpret and transmit their writing, and they were shown its features and given practice using it. In one condition, they were told not to make an diagrams while working, and in another they were given a enn diagram tutorial and instructed to "make one or more enn diagrams before solving the inference problems. Students worked alone and had 3 mins. per problem (for details, see viatt et al., in press). Scoring included the total number of diagrams drawn, total correct enn diagrams, percentage of correct enn diagrams, percentage of correct conceptual inferences, percentage of correct er atim inferences (i.e., correct inferences, given the diagram constructed), and inference errors (e.g., overgeneralizations). Inter- rater reliability averaged 81-99%. Students' averaged 50% correct inferences overall (range 21.1%-78.6%). Results and Discussion Compared with using a non-digital pen, when students used the digital pen interface they drew significantly more enn diagrams per problem by ilcoxon signed ranks test [[ = 1.17 v. 1.25; = 1.76, = 9, p < .04, one- tailed]. They also constructed significantly more correct enn diagrams, ilcoxon [[ = 0.82 v. 1.03; = 2.16, = 16, p < .016, one-tailed], and a higher percentage of correct enn diagrams, ilcoxon [69% v. 83%, respectively; = 1.84, = 15, p < .033]. Figure 1 shows these differences in diagramming due to the tool used. Students' percentage of verbatim correct inferences averaged 89.2% versus 95.2% when using the regular and digital pen tools, a significant difference by ilcoxon = 1.73, = 12, p < .042, one-tailed. As predicted and shown in Figure 2, students' percentage of correct conceptual inferences during diagram- aseden_US
dc.language.isoenen_US
dc.publisherInternational Society of the Learning Sciences (ISLS)en_US
dc.titleComputer Input Capabilities that Stimulate Diagramming and Improved Inferential Reasoning in Low-performing Studentsen_US
dc.typePostersen_US
Appears in Collections:ICLS 2012

Files in This Item:
File SizeFormat 
451-452.pdf141.41 kBAdobe PDFView/Open


Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.