Which science disciplines are pertinent? -Impact of epistemological beliefs on students' choices

Abstract

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ntroduction Division of cognitive labor )&+( +,"#/"8$( I#"J*&( 1,;( 2/E"#*1,%+( "6( $%2+,*262%( 1,;( *+%&,":"I2%1:( K,"J:+;I+( 2,( /";+#,( $"%2+*2+$( +,*12:( 41#2"8$( %",$+[8+,%+$D( R,"J:+;I+( 2$( 8,+4+,:5( ;2$*#2H8*+;( 1,;( J+( 1#+( :15E+#$",$( 2,( /"$*( K,"J:+;I+( ;"/12,$D(\+1:2,I(J2*&(41#2"8$(E#"H:+/$(;+/1,;(;266+#+,*(1,;(;24+#$262+;(K,"J:+;I+(H1%KI#"8,;$D(7"$*($"%2"G $%2+,*262%( 2$$8+$( Q%&+/2%1:( 1;;2*2",$( *"( 6"";'( I+,+*2%( +,I2,++#2,I]( ^+2;:+#'( Z1;:+#'( _EE:+H18/( -( `1::1&1,'( =SSAT(1#+(61#(*""(%"/E:+M(*"(H+(8,;+#$*"";(;++E:5(H5(:15E+#$",$'(H8*(2*(2$(,+4+#*&+:+$$(,+%+$$1#5(6"#(:15E+#$",$( *"( #+1$",( 1,;( *"( ;+%2;+( 1H"8*( *&+$+( 2$$8+$( J2*&( #+I1#;( *"( E+#$",1:( &+1:*&( "#( J2*&( #+I1#;( *"( %242%( E1#*2%2E1*2",D( a15E+#$",$( /8$*( #+:5( ",( +ME+#*$( H1$+;( ",( *&+2#( "J,( 6#1I/+,*1#5( 8,;+#$*1,;2,I( "6( $8%&( 2$$8+$( Q.#"//+'( R2+,&8+$(-(!"#$%&'(=SSATD(B4+,(%&2:;#+,(:+1#,(6#"/(*&+(4+#5(H+I2,,2,I(*&1*(*&+5(&14+(*"(#+:5(",("*&+#$(2,("#;+#( *"( I+*( 2,6"#/1*2",'( *"( 1,$J+#( 1( [8+$*2",'( "#( *"( $":4+( 1( E#"H:+/( Q.+#I$*#"/'( 7"+&:/1,,'( -( ."5+#'( =SSbTD( `&2:;#+,( K,"J( *&1*( *&+5( %1,( 1$K( E1#+,*$( 1,;( E++#$( 26( *&+5( ,++;( *"( K,"J( $"/+*&2,ID( )&+5( ;266+#+,*21*+( J&"( *"( *#8$*( Qc1##2$'( =SSdT'( *&+5( 1#+( 1J1#+( *&1*( E+"E:+( &14+( ;266+#+,*( 1#+1$( "6( +ME+#*2$+'( 1,;( K,"J( &"J( K,"J:+;I+( 2$( %:8$*+#+;(2,(*&+(/2,;$("6("*&+#$(QR+2:(+*(1:D'(=SS@TD(9"#(2,$*1,%+'(2,(1($*8;5(H5(a8*L(1,;(R+2:(Q=SS=T'(Xb(%&2:;#+,( "6(;266+#+,*(1I+(QeG'(?G'(1,;(XG5+1#G":;$T(&1;(*"(f8;I+(J&2%&("6(*J"(+ME+#*$(Q1(%1#(/+%&1,2%("#(1(;"%*"#T(J"8:;( K,"J( /"#+( 1H"8*( 1( $E+%262%( *"E2%D( 0+$8:*$( $&"J( *&1*( *&+( ?G1,;( XG5+1#( ":;$( J+#+( 1H:+( *"( 1**#2H8*+( K,"J:+;I+( %"##+%*:5( H1$+;( ",( $%2+,*262%( E#2,%2E:+$'( J&+#+1$( *&+( eG5+1#( ":;$( E+#6"#/+;( H+**+#( *&1,( %&1,%+( /+#+:5( ",( $*+#+"*5E2%1:( #":+( 2*+/$D( B4+,( %&2:;#+,( &14+( 1,( +1#:5( ,"*2",( "6( *&+( ;242$2",( "6( %"I,2*24+( :1H"#'( *&+5( &14+( 1,( 1$$8/E*2",( J&2%&( +ME+#*$( /2I&*( K,"J( $"/+*&2,I( 1H"8*( J&1*D( U,( *&+( 6"::"J2,I( J+( J2::( %1::( *&2$( K,"J:+;I+( 1H"8*(*&+(O;2$%2E:2,+$g(E+#*2,+,%+P(*"(%+#*12,(2$$8+$D( _,( 8,;+#$*1,;2,I( "6( *&+( E+#*2,+,%+( "6( ;266+#+,*( K,"J:+;I+( 62+:;$( *"( ;266+#+,*( 2$$8+$( /8$*( H+( H1$+;( ",( 1,( 8,;+#$*1,;2,I( "6( *&+( $*#8%*8#+( "6( K,"J:+;I+D( Z%2+,*262%( K,"J:+;I+( &1$( H++,( ;+4+:"E+;( 2,( 1,;( 2$( *18I&*( 2,( 1%1;+/2%( ;2$%2E:2,+$'( 6"#( +M1/E:+( 2,( $%&"":( "#( 1*( 8,24+#$2*2+$( QZ*+4+,$'( h2,+H8#I'( c+##+,K"&:'( -( .+::'( =SSXTD( h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f+%*(*"(%",*2,8"8$(%&1,I+D(h&2:+(2*(J"8:;(H+(;+$2#1H:+(26(:15E+#$",(J"8:;(K,"J(J&"(QJ&2%&(+ME+#*iT(J"8:;( H+(E+#*2,+,*(*"(J&2%&(2$$8+'(2*(%1,(H+(;2662%8:*(1$$+$(J&2%&(;2$%2E:2,+$(1#+(/"#+("#(:+$$(#+:+41,*(6"#(1(*&+/+D(U*(2$( 1,("E+,(+/E2#2%1:([8+$*2",(26($+%",;1#5($%&"":($*8;+,*$(1#+(1H:+(*"(2;+,*265(;2$%2E:2,+$(J&2%&(1#+(E+#*2,+,*(*"(1( %"/E:+M($%2+,*262%(2$$8+D(